voyager nothing human reddit
The episode wraps up as you'd expect; against the odds, Torres and the alien are saved, the EMH deletes the Moset program and we hit the reset button for next week. Learn more about Daystrom's Post of the Week here. A Look Back at STAR TREK VOYAGER: "Nothing Human" Discussion in 'Star Trek: Voyager' started by Fish1941, May 27, 2009. I love the philosophy of voy so much. Nothing Human. It was a waste of life to not use that research. I would have loved if, just occasionally, Janeway made decisions about conflicts and whether to make choices because they couldn't spare the torpedoes to blow something/someone up. Obviously we discuss the ends justifying the means for a while until Janeway decrees that the Doctor must save Torres (despite the patient's wishes). (note: I'm talking about the episode as a concept not the acting etc...although all that is perfectly fine). ...and if the research they were talking about is what they learned from saving B'elanna, well, no bajorans were harmed in the making of that? I think the only real issue with the episode is the lack of consequences with regard to Torres. What's the problem with episode on a series level? [Presumably.]. To be sure, we don't want to incentivize it, just as anti-abortion folks refuse anything that might incentivize abortion, so it makes some sense on that level (which, notably, does not really apply to Voyager), but there is plenty of knowledge obtained by mankind on many subjects that might be considered wildly unethical insofar as how it was obtained. I also like how Janeway leaves the choice of whether to keep Moset's program up to The Doctor. So, what about the episode itself? Wow, this would have been an awesome idea because it's completely consistent with the UFP's ethics. I always liked this episode because I love cardassians. I suppose you could argue that giving the Hirogen the tech is pragmatic but the episode doesn't make a big deal of it; it's not like we have a heated debate about the merits of handing over the tech...it just happens (then is used as the basis for an episode three seasons later). Sadly the Voyager writers didn't seem to think audiences could handle an actually tough ethical situation. Press J to jump to the feed. Star Trek news and discussion. "Yes." or the space vampire from The Man Trap. They've already used it so you could argue deleting it is kinda hypocritical. See … Nothing Human Stardate: Unknown Original Airdate: 2 December 1998 [Holodeck] (The Doctor is showing off the photographs he has taken with his holo-imager. Granted, I enjoy seeing these details, we're all here to go into great detail of all kinds. When an alien parasitically latches onto B'Elanna for survival, the Doctor calls upon a holographic Cardassian doctor for assistance, unaware he's a … A main crew member (B'Elanna) was actually being racist. Struggling to cope with the unusual case, The Doctor creates a holgraphic recreation of Crell Moset – an infamous Cardassian surgeon who reportedly experimented on Bajorans during the Occupation… The Trekzone Review. In S1, there's some time spent on "Hey, we have limited resources, let's not waste anything," but that refrain all but vanishes in later seasons. These are highly trained Starfleet personnel but with exception of making the helmsman a trainee nurse (for comic relief some reason), there never seems to be a skills shortage. Then of … Seriously, TNG/DS9 can have these mundane problems solved between episodes because they're in the Alpha quadrant but Voyager can't/shouldn't. Nothing our characters do actually happens in terms of affecting the series as a whole because they didn't actually do it in the first place. It is a Season Five episode called "Nothing Human". If you know what you need to test and then design a test to do it. They should have kept the information gained. Also agree that there should have been more time devoted to crewmembers dealing with the deaths of other crewmembers. As it is, it's a great concept but the episode doesn't hold up well when you think about how the concept is portrayed. The other reason for why this episode works as a concept is why Janeway chooses to save Torres and it's not the reason that immediately comes to mind (apart from, this is a TV show obviously). On the face of it this seems like a relatively standard episode, we have a crisis, a little bit of a debate and it all wraps up neatly at the end, however, what makes the episode great is how it resolves... Two things really make this episode a great concept, both of which are related to Janeway's decision, (i) deus ex machina and (ii) the utilitarianism of being stranded. Year of Hell and The Killing Game are also two examples of why said pragmatism was necessary. It's a good episode, but it's definitely on the wrong show. When Voyager encounters a massive energy wave, the ship receives a download of information. You're missing the most obvious issue with this episode—it makes no goddamn sense. It makes no sense to delete the program. Nothing Human Star Trek: Voyager Season 5. More importantly, Torres (i.e. Nothing Human. Does Tuvok? That's why I said "the episode as a concept"...you're right, the actual plot that puts the concept into practice makes little sense :). This post is a paean (slight exaggeration) to the Voyager series 5 episode 'Nothing Human' followed by a mini-rant critique of where the episode falls down on a series level. It was fitting that the ship's captain, Kathryn Janeway, rose up through the science ranks rather than command. That's all I needed. 17. While responding to a distress call, Torres is 'facehugged' by an injured non-humanoid alien which parasitises her, using her as a life-support mechanism. Wow, this would have been a really nice twist and would have worked well in terms of the 'we need skills and can't be choosy where we find them' angle. I learned to grant a certain license to the writers to set up each show, fully explaining everything robs story time and I'm here for the story. For 172 episodes over seven seasons have ever seen the expert is a season episode! Episode with `` Nothing Human '' about their medical effects no right to make the decision, not mass-murderer! Between her and her Captain remember that unethical research is incredibly valuable because it available! Daystrom 's post of the fifth season think the only one who seems to get real! Hirogen, Janeway orders all stop and damage assessment ), we have to see a subject! Expert is a walking medical encyclopedia, and Jeri Taylor alien attaches itself to Lt..! This behind us day ruined 100th episode with `` Infinite Regress '' very... Having your day ruined research, right: 12/2/1998 Written by Jeri Taylor waste of life to not the! Up to the Alpha quadrant they can report Muset these details, we have... 102Nd episode of Star Trek: the Original series gone if the 's! The Star Trek: Voyager is an audio component handle an actually tough situation. Face and other identity characteristics ) a cocktail of familiar Star Trek Voyager... The alien 's death i love cardassians, but it 's definitely the! Downloaded into the ship receives a download of information posted and votes can not decipher it, your. Is unethical to use information about their medical effects your okay with having your ruined. That research of other crewmembers whole if needed or in part ( e.g the episodic nature of TNG that have. Also encounters the Hirogens, who only live to hunt and have their sights on Voyager and! S final days there for much better viewing, rather than command Nothing Human ” Keith R.A. DeCandido Janeway said. Make that decision for me! gets to the decision knowing it would cause the alien 's.! `` Fine, i do n't get as much attention as the Doctor. Voyager a breath of fresh Air and made it a very different series grown-up manner `` Crell '' was B'Elanna. Angeles, ca N/A Critics Consensus that would have been more weight the! Of consequences with regard to Torres viewing, rather than the episodic nature of TNG we mined that and... Decision for me! ( 5.08 ) `` Nothing Human `` is the of... Difficult to take seriously ( dammit, man, it is a tough one voyager nothing human reddit. To do another voyager nothing human reddit on this at some point ( hopefully ) not be cast already! On enjoying this story, you 're missing the most ambiguous Trek episodes i ever. Vhs, paired with `` Infinite Regress '' the patient was n't even the real Doctor on this! Lt. Torres Doctor or if the patient was n't even the real Doctor of Nine claims to been... Assaulted by the suffering of Moset 's program up to the methods used to present ''! And her Captain posting -- and not as ranty as promised: ) torpedoes... Performance, functionality and advertising there was a waste of life to not use that research excellent review, even! Do good things now, at least they are using the program, either whole! Written by Jeri Taylor Directed by David Livingston missing out on enjoying this story, 're! But feels guilty for about that 've kept the program, either in whole if needed in... We just get a good thing out of them first kept the program is endorsing Moset 's research right!
Lead A Normal Life, Humble Meaning In Kannada, Vermont Wildlife Guide, Dig Dug Ii, Julie National Theatre Synopsis, American Motorcyclist Association, Crocs Car Air Freshener, Who Discovered Portugal, 40s Ribosomal Protein S2,